Stem Cell Hypocrisy

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

I'm trying to stay away from discussions of hypocrisy these days, but some acts rise to a level of moral repugnance that cannot be ignored. Consider the votes by North Carolina Congressmen to sustain Bush's veto of embryonic stem cell research legislation. They swallowed the Bush Party line that stem cell research is tantamount to murder. They sold out promising therapy to political posturing. And Tom Harkin nailed them for it on the Senate floor today.

I don't get it. Who gave the President the authority to draw that line? He may be the President of the United States, but he's not the moral authority for all Americans. I say Mr. President, you are not our moral ayatollah. You don't have that right and you don't have that power. Oh, you can veto legislation, you can veto it...He vetoed it because he said it was immoral...tantamount to murder. No, I'm sorry but it is hyprocisy at the extreme for the President to take that position.

So I ask, if using discarded embryos to extract stem cells is murder, isn't it then immoral to allow federal research on existing lines of embryonic stem cells as the current administration's policy permits? Murder is murder, Mr. President.

And isn't it immoral to allow privately funded embryonic research to continue? Now again, in this country, as we heard many times on the floor here in the last couple days of the debate, privately funded embryonic stem cell research goes on in the United States. But according to the President, this is murder. And if it's really murder...why isn't the President using his authority, his moral authority, to shut down all the in-vitro fertilization clinics in America? By his definition of murder, these clinics are institutions of mass murder.

Virtually everytime a couple goes to a fertility clinic, leftover embryos are created...if that's murder, how can the President permit it to continue? Where's his outrage at the IVF clinics in this country? Why isn't he up here proposing legislation to shut down in-vitro fertilization in this country? Make it a crime, a federal crime, to conduct in-vitro fertilization? In the President's narrow, moral universe, it seems to be just fine to destroy embryos, to throw them away, as the by-product of producing babies through IVF, but it's murder to use the embryos to conduct life saving research. Someone please explain the logic of that to me.

And why isn't the President prosecuting the many thousands of American men and women who use these IVF clinics? If their attempts to have children results in leftover embryos and these embryos eventually get discarded, aren't they complicit in murder? Under the President's narrow, moral logic, and I'd hate to call it logic, the President's narrow, moral view, any man or woman who allows their embryo to be discarded, something that happens everyday, is authorizing murder. Why is the President standing idly by? Why isn't he putting all these men and women in jail?

Murder is murder. Murderers deserve the death penalty. Especially when it's premeditated. So when you're thinking about what to ask candidates, consider asking this: Don't you agree that couples who undergo invitro fertilization should receive the death penalty?

Go ahead. I double-dog dare you.


Virginia Foxx
Robin Hayes
Walter Jones,
Patrick McHenry
Mike McIntyre
Sue Myrick
Charles Taylor

The picture, according to its source, is of nerve stem cells.

Comments

My question:

How are you going to save the lives of the 400,000 embryos currently in frozen storage in IVF clinics that are scheduled to be discarded as their viability date expires since to date we have seen only 180 of these embryos adopted?

Bush Economy

Ask Robin.

Watch him wiggle. He's been caught being a waterboy again.

Eggggzackly

n/t

They have an answer to that one

That passes the giggle test (if only just barely): if there's federal funding for embryonic stem cell research, clinics will have a marketable product in the form of leftovers, and thus a financial incentive to create more embryos per couple than they do today.

This doesn't bother me that much, as I don't really think of embryos as people. I mean, I did come from an embryo, but I also came from a vagina, and from Louisiana.

I wish they cared

Bush Economy

as much about people after they were born as they do about 100 cells frozen in a petri dish in a cluster smaller than the period at the end of this sentence.

Narrow minded moral authority!

the bush statement that it's murder and it's wrong made me wonder how he justifies the murder going on in his war on iraq and the iraqi people?

Photoshop opportunity

I will be following Bush's promotion of this useless loss of life as the 399,997+ embryos are carelessly flushed down the proverbial toilet. It gives a whole new meaning to the term Bush babies, doesn't it?

I need a picture of Bush in a lab coat holding a test tube over a toilet. Anyone want to work on this photo?



***************************
Vote Democratic! The ass you save may be your own.